|

Business
Journal
Serving San Jose and Silicon Valley
April 23, 1999
Health Care Quarterly
New report finds disparity in health of community
By Cindy Ling
Special to The Business Journal
The findings of a report to assess the health of the community
in Santa Clara County confirmed what many in the industry already
know--there is a widening and evident disparity between groups that
correlates with income and ethnicity.
The report is required every three years for nonprofit hospitals
as a condition of their tax-exempt status (SB697). This is the second
report that has been done since the law passed in 1994. Each hospital
can do the report individually but in Santa Clara County, the nonprofit
hospitals joined forces and invited community organizations to participate
in the process.
The group, the Community Benefits Coalition, also worked with a
similar group in San Mateo County to develop a survey that they
both used this year.
"We now have a tool to use in future evaluations that will
allow us to track and compare changes in the Bay Area," said
Sharon Keating Beauregard of Kaiser Permanente, who co-chaired the
coalition. With the exception of a few areas, the findings showed
that Santa Clara County as a whole is doing well. The county compared
favorably in many areas with the Healthy 2000 goals previously set
by the Department of Health and Human Services as a benchmark for
evaluating health outcomes.
The areas where Santa Clara County fell short were in the percentages
of children receiving immunizations and the rates of sexually transmitted
diseases and tuberculosis.
There were significantly higher rates of infant mortality, juvenile
and domestic violence, teen pregnancy, sexually transmitted diseases,
alcohol and drug abuse, and mental health problems for Hispanics,
African Americans and low-income groups.
"We live in a highly resourceful area," said Todd Hansen,
senior vice president and general counsel for The Health Trust,
a community member of the coalition. "But the affluence only
exacerbates the problems of the poor. Health access was shown to
be directly correlated to income level." The Health Trust was
formed from the proceeds of the sale of Good Samaritan Health System
to Columbia/HCA in 1996.
"It's really a tale of two cities," said Don Bolce, executive
director of Joing Venture: Silicon Valley Network, another coalition
member. The results parallel those of a broader study done by Joint
Venture annually that looks at multiple indicators to identify Silicon
Valley trends. Apparently the income gap has created significant
difference not only in housing and education, but in health outcomes
as well.
In addition, 13.1 percent of residents in Santa Clara County are
uninsured, a troubling statistic that concerns all segments of the
health care industry. The uninsured have poor access to services
and poorer health outcomes due to limited treatment and a lack of
early intervention and preventive care.
"While there is a lot of attention on health care quality
these days, there is little being done to address the problem of
the uninsured. All of the legislative efforts are aimed at improving
health care benefits for those who already have insurance,"
said Mr. Bolce. "This only drives up the costs of insurance
and makes health care insurance even more out of reach for those
who don't have it."
Contrary to what many may think, the uninsured generally do not
include the chronically unemployed, who qualify for government programs
such as Medi-Cal. The uninsured consist primarily of individuals
who work in industries that typically don't provide the employer-sponsored
health benefits; those who work for small businesses and the self-employed;
and part time, temporary workers and independent contractors. With
health premium costs rising again, many fear that some employers
who currently provide benefits for employees may choose to stop,
or may require additional contributions from employees.
The Community Benefits Coalition will be meeting this week to begin
planning next steps. As a result of the previous assessment, the
group provided funding for "The Community Diabetes Project.
These funds were used to help develop a curriculum and training
for lay persons to teach diabetics how to manage their condition.
The project has provided diabetic screenings for over 200 individuals.
Individual members of the council also will be taking the report
back to their respective organizations as a resource for strategic
planning. In addition, the report will be used to drive policy and
funding decisions for both public and private agencies.
"Since lifestyle factors account for over 50 percent of health
outcomes, the findings make a good case for increasing prevention
efforts especially targeting high risk populations," said Guadalupe
Olivas, public health director for Santa Clara County. The full
report is available online at http://www.jointventure.org/initiatives/health/hospital.pdf
Community Benefits Coalition
Members include:
- Alexian Brothers Hospital
- Community Health Partnership
- The Health Trust
- Hospital Council of Northern & Central California, Santa
Clara Section
- Joint Venture: Silicon Valley Network
- Kaiser Permanente, Santa Clara and Santa Teresa
- O'Connor/St. Louise Hospital
- Planetree Health Resource Center
- Santa Clara Family Health Plan
- Santa Clara Valley Medical Center
- Santa Clara Valley Public Health Department
- UCSF/Standford Health Care/Lucile Packard Children's Health
Services
- United Way of Santa Clara County
Cindy Ling is a freelance writer based in San Jose.
|